

A Stimulating and Practical Guide Book
Trekking and Climbing in the Western Alps
very useful guidebook

A Fascinating Exposé

Amongst the greatest of stories...the Raj into the upper reaches of the British Empire. Filled
with the history of Kashmir, Afghanistan and Tibet from this period. This book would be well complimented by Steven Tanner's
Afghanistan for the history of that region.


Quite interestingThe coverage of the material is in some places overly general, going beyond musical topics to such issues as race relations and colonialism. Early in the book, Farrell briefly discusses Edward Said's "Orientalism", and some parts of this book examine Orientalism in music in light of some of Said's ideas. On the other hand, other parts of the book are quite detailed, even discussing individual concerts that took place 100 years ago. This juxtaposition of general comments and details feels at times as if the book was actually written as individual papers, to be published separately, rather than as one long coherent work. In contrast to the broad title, the text focuses mostly on Hindustani classical music, although Carnatic classical music is occasionally mentioned, as well as film music
Farrell's discussions center around the lack of understanding of Hindustani music displayed by British and American audiences and musicians. He describes how British colonialists tried to transcribe Indian music in the Eighteenth century, how British and American audiences couldn't distinguish between fake and authentic Indian music, and how rock musicians tried to play sitar without any understanding of Indian music. He puzzles over why only jazz and rock musicians have experimented with Indian music, and not classical musicians, and why Indian classical music has been interesting to fans of world music, but not Indian pop music. I don't find such issues so mysterious- -after all, classical music is by definition based on a conventional standard, so we wouldn't expect experimentation with Indian music by Western classical musicians. On the other hand, world music fans want to hear something new and different. Indian classical music is certainly different, but Indian pop music, even though it might use some traditional instruments or rhythms, sounds too much like pop music everywhere else to be particularly interesting to outsiders.
I find other facets of the interactions between the West and Indian music to be much more interesting, such as the possible historical links between many classical Western music instruments and classical Indian instruments (the nagaswaram and the oboe, for instance, or the sitar, oud, and guitar). Or the willingness of Indian classical musicians and their audiences to adopt new instruments from the West, such as the violin, saxophone, mandolin, or even Hawaiian steel guitar. Since they are adopting these instruments into their own classical tradition, it seems very different from Western rock musicians experimenting with sitar. From the title of this book, I expected at least some exploration into issues such as these, but Farrell never mentions them.


A Useful Guide to Madeira

Single-minded pursuit of a goal
This book is an odyssey in itself!

Rare account of Indian Army 1971The book traces the historical background to the Indo-Pak War of 1971, the military crackdown by Pakistan on its Eastern province, the escape of 10 million Bengali refugees into India and the eventual involvement of India in a third bloody round with Pakistan.
In a style simple and lucid, combined with the professional touch of a front-line soldier, the General describes the battles fought on the Western Front, with an incisive evaluation in the case of major battles. Depicting these in graphic detail, he gives an account of the role played by Indian gunners, the Honour Titles bestowed on artillery units for their outstanding contribution and the courage displayed by individual officers and men in almost every single action.
The book concludes with a few thought provoking views on India's defence preparedness - stressing on self-reliance in military hardware, greater interface between the politician and the military, full activation of the concept of a National Security Council, and the need to appoint the Chief of Defence Staff, while highlighting, in particular, the vital requirement to strengthen the artillery punch of the Indian Army.
A valuable contribution to India's military history and national security.


A Disappointment
Illuminating cultureThe book is an short and an easy read, but with further reflection, the depth of the themes revealed herein can be worthy of a lifetime of study.
This would have been a five-star book if the typeface was more readable. Unfortunately the designer didn't realize that most of us read better with serifs. People with astigmatism: beware.


Related Vacation Book Subjects:
india
More Pages: Western India Page 1
2
If you like this site (or even if you don't), please also visit Financial Book Review for money matters, Houseware Reviews for your home and vacuum needs, Electronics Reviews Now for gadget and device reviews as well as Book Reviews by Subject.